The Supreme Court has suspended the life sentences of two men convicted in the 2002 gang rape of Bilkis Bano and the killing of members of her family, and ordered them released on bail while their appeals are decided.
The two men are Bipinchand Kanaiyalal Joshi and Pradip Ramanlal Modhiya, two of the eleven men sentenced to life imprisonment by a Mumbai special court in 2008. A bench of Justices M M Sundresh and Prasanna B Varale passed the order on October 28, 2026; it was uploaded to the court’s website some days later.
The bench gave three reasons: both men have spent “more than seventeen years” in custody, one of them (Joshi) has a severe disability, and their appeal raises questions of fact and law that still have to be decided. The trial court will fix the conditions of their release.
What the order does and does not do: it suspends the sentence pending appeal. It does not set aside the convictions, which stand until the Supreme Court rules on the appeal itself.
Why the court granted bail
- Time already served. The bench recorded that both appellants have been in custody for more than 17 years.
- Disability. One appellant, Joshi, has a severe handicap.
- Open questions on appeal. The court said there are issues of both fact and law still to be decided.
- The FIR point. The court also noted that one of the two was not named in the original FIR and was brought into the case almost three years later. Published reports of the order do not say which of the two this refers to.
The appeal challenges the Bombay High Court’s judgment of May 4, 2017, which upheld the convictions and life sentences of all eleven men. The Supreme Court issued notice on the appeal on March 17, 2026, asking the governments of Gujarat and Maharashtra to respond.
The arguments in court
| For Joshi and Modhiya | For the prosecution | |
| Counsel | Senior advocates Siddharth Luthra and Sonia Mathur | Additional Solicitor General Rajkumar Bhaskar Thakare |
| Main argument | The two were tried alongside nine others for murder and gang rape and given life terms plus fines; they have served over 17 years and their appeal raises live issues | This is a gang rape case; the trial court and High Court weighed the evidence and the gravity of the crimes before convicting |
| Result | Sentence suspended, bail granted on terms to be set by the trial court | Opposition to bail not accepted at this stage |
The remission fight, 2022–2024
This is not the first time these men have been freed early. In May 2022, acting on a petition by convict Radheshyam Shah, the Supreme Court told Gujarat to decide the convicts’ remission plea under the state’s 1992 policy. On August 15, 2022, Gujarat granted remission to all eleven. They walked out of Godhra sub-jail and were greeted with sweets and garlands, which set off nationwide protests. More than 6,000 people, women’s rights activists among them, petitioned the Supreme Court to reverse the decision.
On January 8, 2024, a bench of Justices B V Nagarathna and Ujjal Bhuyan struck down the remission orders. It held that Gujarat had no power to grant remission because the trial had been moved to Mumbai in 2004, which made Maharashtra the appropriate government. It also found that the May 2022 order had been obtained by fraud and by suppressing material facts. The court refused the convicts’ requests for more time, and all eleven surrendered at Godhra sub-jail late on January 21, 2024. A later plea by two convicts for interim bail, pending fresh remission decisions, was turned away as misconceived.
Why the new order is different: the 2022 release was an executive act of clemency by a state government. The October 2026 order is a judicial step on a separate track: an appeal court suspending a sentence while it re-examines the conviction itself.
What happens next
- Bail conditions. The trial court will set the terms (sureties, reporting, travel limits) before the two men are released.
- The appeal itself. The Supreme Court still has to hear Joshi and Modhiya’s challenge to the 2017 High Court judgment. It could uphold the convictions, in which case they would go back to prison, or set them aside.
- The other nine. The bail order covers only these two appellants. The remaining nine were last reported to be serving their life sentences after the January 2024 surrender.
Senior advocate Shobha Gupta has represented Bilkis Bano without fee since 2003, from the trial court through the High Court to the Supreme Court.
Notes on conflicting figures
- Family members killed. The prosecution’s case and the courts’ judgments speak of seven members of Bilkis Bano’s family, including her three-year-old daughter. Some reports give a higher total of 14 (or 17) for everyone killed in the attack.
- Pregnancy. Most reports say she was 21 and five months pregnant; at least one recent report says three months.
- Date the order went online. One report says it was uploaded on a Thursday, another on a Sunday.
- Spellings. Names are transliterated differently across outlets (Kanaiyalal/Kanhaiyalal, Pradip/Pradeep, Thakare/Thakre).


