Every Indian Muslim, particularly those concerned about the future of the coming generations, must ask themselves an important question today: Are we genuinely preparing our community to face the challenges of the future, or have we confined our entire struggle for progress to just one issue — educating our children?
There is absolutely no doubt that education is the foundation of progress. We need doctors, engineers, lawyers, civil servants, researchers, teachers, entrepreneurs and professionals in every field. But is that all we need? Does earning a degree automatically guarantee dignity? Can professional qualifications eliminate social discrimination? Does economic success automatically ensure constitutional rights, social acceptance, political representation and institutional participation?
If the answer to these questions is no, then it is time to reassess our understanding of community development.
This article is not against education. Rather, it is an appeal to move beyond a limited understanding of education and think about the comprehensive development of our community. We need education, but we also need awareness. We need professional success, but we also need social dignity. We need political participation, but we also need accountability and responsibility. Above all, we need unity, a collective vision and a strong sense of responsibility.
To understand our present, we must look at our past. Muslims have made significant contributions to India’s social, educational, intellectual, cultural and political history. Their contributions to the freedom struggle, journalism, literature, education, administration and social reform cannot be overlooked.
Our community produced scholars, intellectuals, reformers, lawyers, writers and political leaders who understood the importance of knowledge and active participation in public life.
Institutions such as Darul Uloom Deoband, Nadwatul Ulama and Aligarh Muslim University played important roles in the intellectual development of the Muslim community through different educational approaches. These institutions demonstrated that religious knowledge and modern education could coexist and complement each other.
Many scholars, intellectuals and social reformers of the pre-independence era received their early education in traditional religious learning environments. Their journeys demonstrate that religious education and strong moral foundations do not prevent individuals from contributing to modern knowledge, science, politics, administration or social reform.
We should not idealise the past while ignoring its shortcomings. Inequality, internal divisions and unequal access to education existed even then. Nevertheless, it is worth reflecting on how our educational traditions, intellectual institutions, religious scholarship and social networks once provided a foundation for wider participation in public life.
The question is not whether we should return to the past. The real question is: Which valuable aspects of our past have we managed to preserve, and how seriously are we working to strengthen them for future generations?
The Sachar Committee Report: Two Decades Later, What Has Really Changed?
The Sachar Committee Report, presented in 2006, brought national attention to the educational, economic and social conditions of Muslims in India. It highlighted significant gaps in literacy, educational participation, employment, access to banking facilities and representation in government institutions. Even after nearly two decades, the report remains an important document in discussions about Muslim development.
However, our challenges are not limited to the statistics presented in one report. Even today, Muslim families in several parts of the country face difficulties in accessing quality education, stable employment, business opportunities, institutional support and equal participation in public life.
Educational backwardness, economic vulnerability, inadequate professional representation, social marginalisation, lack of legal awareness and weak community institutions continue to be serious challenges.
At the same time, we must have the courage to acknowledge our internal shortcomings. Competition between organisations, leadership disputes, lack of transparency, personal ambitions, poor coordination and the absence of long-term planning have frequently weakened our collective strength.
It is easy to discuss what others have done wrong. It is far more difficult, but equally necessary, to examine where we ourselves have failed.
An Important Perspective: The Sachar Report Still Awaits Its Due
Recently, I came across a thought-provoking newspaper article titled “The Sachar Report Awaits Its Due”, written by Retired IPS Officer Abdur Rahman, a former Inspector General of Police.
His article deserves particular attention because it revisits the Sachar Committee’s recommendations and raises serious questions about their implementation over the past two decades.
Abdur Rahman is also the author of the book Denial and Deprivation: Indian Muslims after the Sachar Committee and Rangnath Mishra Commission Reports. His administrative experience and sustained engagement with the subject make his observations particularly relevant to this discussion.
In his article, he recalls that the High-Level Committee chaired by Justice (Retd.) Rajinder Sachar submitted its report to then Prime Minister Dr Manmohan Singh on 17 November 2006. The report was subsequently tabled in Parliament on 30 November 2006.
The committee examined several dimensions of Muslim life, including population, education, economic conditions, unemployment, banking facilities, access to basic infrastructure and representation in government employment.
One of the central concerns raised by Abdur Rahman is that the recommendations of the Sachar Committee did not receive the attention and implementation they deserved.
Although certain initiatives, including pre-matric and post-matric scholarship schemes and the Multi-Sectoral Development Programme, were implemented, several other important recommendations remained largely unfulfilled.
He specifically draws attention to recommendations such as the creation of a National Data Bank, an Equal Opportunity Commission and a Diversity Index. These initiatives were intended to improve transparency, measure representation and promote equal opportunities for disadvantaged communities.
His article also discusses the changes in government policy following 2014, arguing that several initiatives introduced during the previous government were either discontinued or rendered ineffective.
Another particularly concerning observation in his article is the changing nature of public discourse surrounding Muslims. He argues that the community, which was once discussed primarily in the context of development and socio-economic inclusion, is increasingly being viewed through the lens of security and identity.
He also raises concerns about discrimination, hate speech, social humiliation, mob lynching and the fear created by bulldozer actions.
The legal and factual circumstances of individual incidents must, of course, be examined separately. However, the broader concerns about insecurity, discrimination and social exclusion deserve serious public attention.
After reading his article, one fundamental question arises:
If the educational, economic and social challenges of the Muslim community were clearly identified in 2006, where do we stand nearly two decades later?
Have we allowed the Sachar Committee Report to remain confined to political speeches, public discussions and election-time promises? Has there been an independent assessment of the implementation of its recommendations? Have our own community organisations evaluated their achievements and shortcomings in light of the report?
There is another important dimension that deserves attention. Governments have a responsibility to formulate policies and implement welfare programmes. However, our own community institutions also have a responsibility to assess the actual condition of the people they claim to serve.
How many students have we helped through scholarships? How many young people have we connected with employment opportunities? How many families have benefited from government welfare schemes? How many effective legal assistance platforms have we established? Do we have reliable data and reports that can answer these questions?
The article by Abdur Rahman does more than remind us of the government’s responsibility. It also encourages us to examine our own collective performance.
The purpose of revisiting the Sachar Report should not merely be to revive old grievances. Its real purpose should be to address, with greater seriousness, planning and accountability, the challenges that were identified nearly two decades ago.
I sincerely appreciate Abdur Rahman for bringing this important issue back into public discussion. His article reminds us that preparing reports alone does not transform society. Real change requires political will, effective implementation of policies, institutional cooperation and active participation from the community.
Is Education the Only Answer to Every Problem?
Over the past several years, we have repeatedly heard that education is the only solution to every problem faced by the Muslim community.
This argument is important, particularly considering the difficulties faced by economically weaker families. However, when one important issue becomes the only priority, there is a risk that several equally serious concerns will be neglected.
Let us ask some straightforward questions.
If a Muslim student works hard, earns excellent qualifications, clears competitive examinations and becomes a senior government officer, do all questions concerning identity, equal treatment and professional dignity automatically disappear?
If a young lawyer earns an LL.B. degree but does not receive practical guidance, professional networking opportunities or access to the right platforms, is a degree alone sufficient?
If a family manages to provide higher education to its children but continues to face economic insecurity, social discrimination and unequal institutional opportunities, can we call that complete empowerment?
Education provides knowledge, opens doors and strengthens individual capabilities. However, strong institutions, legal awareness, social consciousness, economic strength, professional networks and collective efforts are equally necessary to access and protect those opportunities.
We must stop treating education and other community issues as competing priorities. All these dimensions are interconnected. Neglecting one weakens the entire structure.
When Professional Achievement Meets Questions of Equal Treatment
Recent incidents also compel us to examine the difference between individual achievement and institutional dignity.
The case of IPS officer Bushara Bano from West Bengal deserves attention. In September 2026, she was transferred from her position as Additional Superintendent of Police, Kharagpur, to the post of Deputy Commandant in the Fourth Battalion of the State Armed Police.
The controversy arose after she shared an inspirational video about her journey in the civil services. In the video, she used expressions such as ‘Assalamu Alaikum’, ‘InshaAllah’ and ‘JazakAllah’. A right-wing organisation reportedly objected to the use of these expressions and submitted a complaint to the West Bengal Home Secretary. Her transfer followed this controversy.
However, the official transfer order reportedly cited ‘public interest’, and the state government described it as an administrative transfer. Therefore, it has not been officially established that her religious identity was the reason behind the transfer. Nevertheless, the sequence of events and the controversy surrounding it raise important questions.
Can a simple religious greeting by a qualified woman civil servant become a subject of public controversy? Should an officer’s professional impartiality be judged by her work or by her religious identity and personal expression?
Another incident in West Bengal also attracted attention. Trinamool Congress MP Mahua Moitra alleged that three senior Muslim officers — IPS officers Syed Waqar Raza and Javed Shamim, and IAS officer Khalil Ahmed — were excluded from certain official meetings and protocol events during Union Home Minister Amit Shah’s visits in July and August 2026.
According to Moitra, during a border security review meeting held in Siliguri in July, a senior police officer was allegedly asked to leave the meeting, while another officer was reportedly asked not to attend. She also alleged that IAS officer Khalil Ahmed was asked to leave a meeting on law and order and disaster management held in Kolkata. Similar incidents were alleged during the August visit.
Mahua Moitra subsequently raised the matter before the United Nations Special Rapporteur on Minority Issues. However, these allegations have not been independently established. They must therefore be treated as serious allegations requiring clarification and investigation, rather than as conclusively proven instances of discrimination.
These incidents should not be used merely to generate anger or advance political arguments. Instead, they should encourage a serious discussion about equality, institutional impartiality, constitutional values and the professional dignity of every citizen.
If an individual is educated, qualified and reaches a senior government position, yet their religious identity becomes a greater subject of discussion than their professional identity, are we genuinely building a society based on equal opportunity and dignity?
This is precisely why our vision cannot remain limited to degrees. We also need constitutional awareness, strong legal institutions, professional associations, collective representation and the courage to raise our voices through democratic means to protect our rights.
Religious and Modern Education: Why Must We Choose Between the Two?
One of the most concerning aspects of our educational thinking is the growing divide between religious and worldly education.
In some sections of society, religious education is considered sufficient in itself. In others, there is a perception that modern education requires leaving behind traditional Madarsa education.
But why should our children have to choose between these two important dimensions of knowledge?
Did many of our earlier scholars, intellectuals and social reformers not receive their foundational education in traditional religious environments? Did their early religious education prevent them from understanding modern society, participating in public discussions, joining the freedom struggle or developing intellectually?
The educational journeys of several historical personalities demonstrate that traditional learning and modern intellectual development can progress together, although the educational systems and opportunities of those times were different from today.
We must ask ourselves whether we have created an artificial wall between different forms of knowledge, thereby weakening the foundations of our educational tradition.
Children should be taught to read, question, reason, explore and understand the world. At the same time, they must develop character, moral responsibility, religious understanding, honesty, compassion and accountability.
We need scientists who understand ethics, lawyers who value justice, doctors who respect human dignity, entrepreneurs who understand social responsibility and civil servants who treat every citizen equally.
The question is not which form of education is superior or which institution is more important.
The real question is whether our education system is producing knowledgeable, capable, ethical and responsible human beings.
In the name of modernity, we must not abandon our roots. Equally, in the name of tradition, we must not reject modern knowledge. A strong foundation gives us the ability to face the challenges of a changing world with confidence.
Political Participation Must Go Beyond Supporting Political Parties
Another serious issue before us concerns our understanding of political participation.
Much of our community’s discussion revolves around which political party to support, which leader to trust and which political organisation can provide us with security or representation.
Political participation is our democratic right. However, permanent dependence on political parties is not a sustainable strategy for the future.
Communal polarisation and religious identity are increasingly being used in electoral politics. Some political parties benefit from division, while others present themselves as the only alternative and seek political advantage through that positioning.
In such an environment, ordinary citizens often become trapped in emotional political debates instead of discussing their rights, responsibilities and long-term interests.
We must develop an independent and principle-based approach towards politics. Political parties and elected representatives should be evaluated on the basis of their work, policies, constitutional commitments, public accountability and treatment of all citizens.
If a government takes a good decision, it deserves appreciation. If a political representative works for public welfare, that contribution deserves recognition. But if a decision is discriminatory, unjust or contrary to constitutional values, we must also have the courage to question it.
Our loyalty must be towards justice, constitutional values and the welfare of society, not towards the identity of any particular political leader or party.
Supporting a political party is a choice, but raising one’s voice against injustice is a responsibility.
We cannot delegate this responsibility entirely to politicians, religious leaders or organisations. Every individual must contribute according to their knowledge, position and capacity.
Unity Must Become a Working Principle, Not Just a Slogan
We often speak about unity, but unity cannot survive on slogans alone. It requires a transformation in the way our institutions function.
How many of our organisations have clear, long-term objectives? How many publish transparent reports about their activities and financial transactions? How many regularly evaluate their performance? How many are willing to cooperate with other organisations without placing leadership, publicity or personal influence at the centre?
These are questions we must seriously ask ourselves.
An educational institution should be evaluated by the quality of education it provides and the lives it transforms. A social organisation should be assessed by the problems it solves. A religious institution should be recognised for the knowledge, values and public service it promotes. A political platform should be judged by its accountability and contribution to society.
Our institutions must become instruments of collective development, not centres of individual influence.
Our opinions, approaches and ideologies may differ. This is natural in any diverse society. But can we work together on common issues such as education, employment, legal awareness, social welfare, economic empowerment and constitutional rights?
Unity does not mean that everyone must think alike. Unity means that our differences must not prevent us from working together.
What Kind of Future Are We Building for the Next Generation?
When we discuss the future, our imagination often remains limited to professional qualifications.
We dream of our children becoming doctors, engineers, civil servants and successful entrepreneurs. All these aspirations are valid, but they should form only one part of a much larger vision.
What kind of society will these children inherit? Will they have strong educational institutions? Will they have employment and entrepreneurial opportunities? Will they understand their constitutional rights? Will they be able to participate confidently in public life? Will they inherit institutions that are transparent, accountable and capable of addressing their problems?
We must prepare our children not merely to secure jobs, but also to create employment opportunities for others. Not merely to acquire positions, but to contribute meaningfully to society. Not merely to achieve personal success, but to become responsible citizens and leaders.
This requires a multidimensional approach.
We need institutions that provide quality education, scholarships, research opportunities and career guidance. We need economic networks that promote employment, entrepreneurship and professional development. We need legal assistance and awareness platforms that help ordinary citizens understand their constitutional rights.
Women and young people must receive meaningful opportunities to participate in institutional leadership. Character and responsibility must be strengthened through religious and moral education. Professional platforms should be developed to provide guidance and cooperation for lawyers, doctors, engineers, teachers and entrepreneurs.
Most importantly, our efforts must not remain limited to announcements and conferences. We need reliable data, research, measurable objectives and regular evaluations so that the actual results of our initiatives can be assessed.
Our goal should not merely be to produce a handful of successful individuals who manage to overcome their circumstances and move ahead. Our goal should be to build a system in which thousands of capable individuals can progress through education, opportunity, dignity and collective support.
Strong Roots Are Essential for Standing Through Every Storm
Nature offers us a simple but powerful lesson.
A tree may grow tall, carry beautiful leaves and appear strong from the outside. But if its roots are weak, a powerful storm can bring it down.
The same principle applies to society.
Our roots are our values, religious understanding, intellectual heritage, educational foundations, moral character, social institutions and sense of collective responsibility.
If we focus only on visible achievements and neglect these foundations, our progress will remain weak and temporary.
We may produce qualified individuals, but we will fail to build a strong social structure that supports them. We may establish institutions, but fail to develop a culture of accountability. We may achieve political visibility, but fail to create meaningful influence.
The strength of a tree is not determined merely by how high its branches grow, but by how deeply its roots reach into the ground.
This does not mean returning to some imagined golden age of the past. It means preserving what is valuable, improving what is weak and building what is missing.
A community that forgets its roots may achieve temporary success, but a community that strengthens its foundations can remain firm even in the most difficult storms and achieve lasting progress.
The Responsibility to Question, Correct and Contribute
Perhaps the most important question is not what governments, political parties or other communities are doing. The real question is: What are we collectively doing to address our own challenges?
Do our organisations work through mutual coordination? Are our leaders accountable to the people they claim to represent? Are our institutions transparent? Do our educated professionals contribute to society? Are we providing adequate opportunities to our youth? Do we raise our voices when constitutional rights are questioned? Can we put aside institutional and ideological differences to support one another?
We must move from emotional reactions to organised action, from temporary campaigns to long-term planning, and from personal ambitions to collective goals.
Every section of society has a role to play. Teachers must educate, lawyers must protect rights, entrepreneurs must create employment opportunities, scholars must provide guidance, journalists must deliver accurate information, professionals must mentor young people and youth must participate actively in social initiatives.
No single individual or organisation can solve every problem. But every individual and institution can contribute towards a shared vision.
Most importantly, responsibility must begin with us.
Questioning a leader is not disloyalty. Demanding transparency is not disrespect. Criticising the shortcomings of an organisation does not mean opposing its good work. In fact, constructive criticism is essential for institutional development.
We must learn to appreciate what is right and oppose what is wrong, irrespective of the individual or organisation involved.
We are living in a period when our decisions, priorities and institutional choices will influence the lives of generations to come.
Our children will not judge us merely by the number of speeches we delivered, meetings we organised or political parties we supported. They will judge us by the opportunities we created for them, the institutions we strengthened, the values we preserved and the courage we demonstrated in confronting challenges.
We must not make the mistake of believing that one achievement will automatically resolve every problem. Education is indispensable, but economic strength, social unity, constitutional awareness, political accountability, institutional transparency and a strong moral foundation are equally necessary.
We cannot leave our future entirely in the hands of one political party, depend on one organisation to solve every problem or believe that one educational initiative will transform the entire community.
This responsibility belongs to all of us.
Our right is not merely to support political parties or strengthen organisations. Our responsibility also includes questioning them, appreciating their good work, opposing wrongdoing and demanding accountability — each person according to their capacity, position and responsibility.
There is still time. Time to learn from our mistakes. Time to strengthen our institutions, resolve internal differences and develop a shared vision for the future.
But emotional speeches alone will not be enough. We need sincerity, courage, planning, mutual cooperation and sustained efforts.
We must educate our children, shape their character, secure their opportunities, protect their dignity and prepare them to make meaningful contributions to the development of our country.
The future of Muslims in India will not be determined merely by the challenges they face today. It will be shaped by the wisdom, resilience and collective responsibility with which they respond to those challenges.
Let us not leave behind a generation that has degrees but no direction, qualifications but no opportunities, dreams but no institutional support, and an identity but no dignity. Let us build a generation that is rich in knowledge, strong in character, confident in its identity, conscious of its rights, responsible towards society and committed to the progress of India.
The question is no longer whether change is necessary. The real question is whether we have the courage to transform ourselves, unite around common goals and accept the responsibility of building the future we desire.
The future will not be secured merely by what we demand; it will be shaped by what we collectively build.
A Special Note to Readers and Community Leaders
This article is presented solely for reference, introspection and constructive discussion. Its purpose is not to demotivate any individual, organisation, community or section of society, nor is it intended to undermine anyone’s confidence or spread negativity.
The questions and examples presented in this article are intended to help us understand our realities, recognise our shortcomings and explore new directions for improvement. Discussion of challenges should not lead to despair; it should inspire positive change.
We must appreciate our achievements, encourage individuals and organisations doing commendable work within the community, and at the same time offer constructive suggestions wherever improvement is needed.
Our intention is not to discourage anyone, but to inspire one another. It is not to criticise for the sake of criticism, but to awaken a sense of collective responsibility. The purpose is not merely to highlight mistakes, but to learn from them and create a better path for the generations to come.
Our discussions should ultimately lead not to disappointment, but to hope, unity, confidence and a renewed commitment to collective action.
Acknowledgement and References
Special acknowledgement is due to Retired IPS Officer Abdur Rahman for his thought-provoking newspaper article, “The Sachar Report Awaits Its Due.”
The discussion in this article concerning the Sachar Committee’s recommendations, their incomplete implementation and the continuing challenges faced by Indian Muslims is specifically inspired by and draws upon Abdur Rahman’s published article.
His observations have been acknowledged and incorporated with due credit. The broader arguments, reflections and recommendations concerning education, political participation, community institutions, social responsibility and the future of Muslims in India represent the author’s own perspective.
His book, Denial and Deprivation: Indian Muslims after the Sachar Committee and Rangnath Mishra Commission Reports, is also an important reference in this context.
I sincerely appreciate Abdur Rahman for bringing this important subject back into public discussion and encouraging a deeper examination of the Sachar Committee’s unfinished agenda.


