On 2 November 2026, Delhi Police personnel, led by an ACP, gathered outside Police Headquarters. Their grievance was two transfers. After a scuffle at Shahdara police station on 23 October, in which an advocate suffered a serious head injury, district court lawyers stopped work. Within days, the ACP of Gandhi Nagar and the Shahdara SHO were transferred. The gathering primarily wanted both restored. What happened on 23 October remains contested: lawyers alleged that an officer threatened them during a meeting and waved a loaded revolver, while the police registered a case against 15 to 20 lawyers for abusing officers and obstructing work. The legal question raised by the protest does not depend on it.
The DCP (New Delhi) arrived with a line that now defines the episode: personnel should not behave like protesters. Commissioner Anurag Kumar later held a Sampark Sabha, an open interaction session reportedly attended by around 500 personnel, and assured them of prompt action on genuine concerns. Reports on 3 November said the Ministry of Home Affairs had suspended the ACP under Rule 10 of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965, with disciplinary proceedings contemplated. The DCP’s appeal was more than a plea for decorum. Perhaps unintentionally, it was a statement of law.
Do Police Have A Right To Protest?
For citizens, the right is read into Article 19(1)(a) and (b). In Mazdoor Kisan Shakti Sangathan v. Union of India (2018), the Supreme Court treated peaceful protest as a fundamental right and refused to accept a blanket ban at Jantar Mantar. Government servants are not wholly outside it either. In Kameshwar Prasad v. State of Bihar (1962), the Court struck down Rule 4-A of the Bihar Government Servants’ Conduct Rules, 1956, in so far as it barred government servants from peaceful demonstrations over service matters, holding that it violated Articles 19(1)(a) and (b), but upheld the ban on strikes, finding no fundamental right to strike.
Police stand on different ground. Article 33 allows Parliament to restrict or abrogate Part III rights of forces charged with maintaining public order, so that they can discharge their duties and keep discipline.
What The 1966 Law Says
Parliament used that power to enact the Police Forces (Restriction of Rights) Act, 1966. Under Section 3(1), no police member may, without express sanction, belong to a trade union or political association, join any outside body that is not purely social, recreational or religious, or communicate with the press or publish any book, letter or document, except in good-faith discharge of duty or for purely literary, artistic or scientific purposes. Section 3(2) bars meetings and demonstrations for political or other prescribed purposes. Section 4 punishes a breach of Section 3 with up to two years’ imprisonment, a fine of up to ₹2,000, or both.
The prescribed purposes are in Rule 3 of the 1966 Rules. Personnel may not join a meeting or demonstration to protest the Act or Rules or disciplinary action against themselves or colleagues, or for any purpose connected with remuneration, conditions of service, work or living. On a plain reading, a gathering over colleagues’ transfers falls within Rule 3(c), as a matter of conditions of service, and arguably Rule 3(b). The other demands, concerning the lawyers, sit less comfortably within it. So far, the reported response is a service-law suspension, not a prosecution under Section 4.
Courts have not helped challengers. In Delhi Police Non-Gazetted Karamchari Sangh v. Union of India (1986), the Supreme Court upheld the Act and Rules against challenges under Articles 14 and 19(1)(c). It held that recognition of an association is not itself a fundamental right, and that discipline is the foremost requirement of a police force. The case concerned association; the limit on demonstrations under Article 19(1)(a) and (b) was not squarely tested. The Bombay High Court later rejected a plea to form a police association. On service matters, then, police have no protected right to demonstrate.
Why They Protest Anyway
The 1966 scheme silences the protest, not the grievance. A 2019 survey of nearly 12,000 personnel across 21 states, the Status of Policing in India Report by Common Cause and CSDS, found an average 14-hour working day, about half of personnel with no weekly off, and four in five not paid for overtime. The legal backdrop is an old always-on-duty principle: Section 22 of the Police Act 1861, mirrored in Section 24 of the Delhi Police Act 1978. A constable challenged both provisions in the Delhi High Court in 2015, but in September 2025 the petition was disposed of as infructuous after the petitioner retired, with liberty to file a PIL.
After a 1996 PIL by former DGPs Prakash Singh and N.K. Singh, the Supreme Court issued seven directions on 22 September 2006 in Prakash Singh v. Union of India. They include minimum two-year tenures for DGPs and operational officers, including SHOs, and a Police Establishment Board to decide transfers, postings and promotions up to Deputy Superintendent rank. These address arbitrary transfers, though whether the Shahdara transfers were arbitrary, or reviewed by any board, is not publicly known. The Model Police Act, 2006, drafted by the Sorabjee Committee, recommended an average eight-hour duty day, extendable to twelve hours in exceptional cases, a weekly day off or compensation, and a welfare bureau. Twenty years on, states remain only partly compliant, and contempt petitions on non-compliance are still pending.
What Other Democracies Do: The common pattern abroad is no strikes, but an institutional voice
United Kingdom: Section 64 of the Police Act 1996 bars officers from trade unions and from associations seeking to influence pay, pensions or conditions; the statutory Police Federation of England and Wales speaks for them instead. Two serving officers are challenging that ban under Article 11 of the European Convention. In August 2025, the then Home Secretary accepted that it interferes with that right, while calling the interference limited, but the Home Office and the Police Federation have since sought to stop the case at the permission stage.
Germany: The Gewerkschaft der Polizei is a genuine trade union and a member of the German Trade Union Confederation, yet in 2018 the Federal Constitutional Court upheld the strike ban for career civil servants, the status most German police officers hold.
France and Strasbourg: In Matelly v. France (2014), the European Court of Human Rights held that a blanket ban on gendarmes, who are part of France’s military, joining union-like groups violated Article 11.
Canada: In Mounted Police Association of Ontario v. Canada (2015), the Supreme Court of Canada held that excluding RCMP members from meaningful collective bargaining breached the Charter’s freedom of association.
India’s position is not uniform. Kerala has had a recognised police association since 1979, and Section 109 of the Kerala Police Act, 2011 lets the government permit police associations. In September 2026 the Kerala High Court quashed a government order restructuring the police associations as a violation of Article 19; the State’s appeal and a PIL seeking guidelines are pending. Delhi’s Non-Gazetted Karamchari Sangh, by contrast, was derecognised in 1971, and the Rules let the Inspector General decide where meetings are held, send observers, bar outsiders and suspend recognition. The real question is why Delhi has none. On 4 November 2026, the Madras High Court said that merely submitting a representation seeking permission to form an association is not misconduct.
A Voice Without A Strike
India need not give police the right to strike or march; discipline is Article 33’s legitimate concern. But a blanket ban on assembling over conditions of work is defensible only if a real channel for grievances exists. A Sampark Sabha at the Commissioner’s discretion is a courtesy, not a right. A public interest petition listed before the Delhi High Court on 6 November asks the court to examine the protest under the 1966 Act.
Three steps would help: an independent statutory representative body, drawing on Kerala’s experience and the Federation model, but with the independence Strasbourg and Ottawa demand; genuine implementation of the Prakash Singh tenure and Establishment Board directions, so that transfers do not become bargaining chips; and legislation fixing the Model Police Act’s duty hours.
A force told not to behave like protesters must be given somewhere else to be heard.
The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of FoEJ Media.


