Kishtwar SPO Killings: Claims, Gaps and the Security Picture

Date:

Two Special Police Officers, Babi Chand (57) and Rashpal Kumar (45), were found shot dead in the Dachhan forest of Kishtwar on 12 November 2026, and their service rifles were gone. Officials treat it as a militant attack. Congress chief Tariq Hameed Karra wants Army fire in a case of mistaken identity ruled out.

BJP MLA Shagun Parihar said mosque announcements preceded the killings, but named no mosque and gave no evidence, The Wire reported. The killings land in a year that, before November, had recorded only two security-force deaths across Jammu and Kashmir.

Timeline

Five days took the case from a missing-persons search to a political fight over who fired.

Date (2026)What happenedSource
16 NovCongress and BJP both demand a probe. BJP legislator R S Pathania calls Karra’s theory unsubstantiated and asks Congress to apologise.Daily Pioneer
14–15 NovLeader of Opposition Sunil Sharma and Parihar visit the families. BJP objects that the bodies were carried in a dumper truck and asks why two SPOs crossed a forest with one INSAS and one .303 rifle.Daily Pioneer, Aaj Tak
13 NovBoth men are cremated in their home village, Kiyar.Aaj Tak
12 NovBullet-riddled bodies found in the Dachhan forest; rifles missing. A cordon-and-search starts in the Dachhan–Warwan belt. Chief Minister Omar Abdullah condoles.Kashmir Life, Kashmir Images
10 or 11 NovThe two SOG men leave the Kiyar camp to relieve a 17 Rashtriya Rifles base at Dharna, Marwah. They never arrive; gunshots are reported in the forest.Kashmir Life, Archyde/NDTV

Where reports disagree

Even the basic facts differ between outlets, and two of the gaps bear directly on the mistaken-identity question.

DetailOne versionAnother version
Day they went missing10 Nov (Kashmir Life, Organiser)11 Nov (The Wire, Daily Pioneer)
Why they were in the forestRotation duty to the Dharna Army post (police account)A hunting trip, in civilian clothes (Karra, citing his district president)
Who was with themTravelling as a pair to relieve the post“On patrol duty along with Army personnel” (Kashmir Thunder)
Where they were foundDachhan forestDherna Top area (Kashmir Thunder)
Rashpal Kumar’s age4540 (Kashmir Images)
SpellingBabi ChandBobby Chand

The competing claims

None of the four political claims has been backed by evidence made public so far; only the official account rests on physical facts (the missing rifles).

ClaimMade byEvidence offeredPushback
Mosque announcements were made before the killings; someone is leaking intelligenceShagun Parihar, BJP MLA, at the wreath-layingNone. No mosque or wording named; she declined The Wire’s callsIslami Markaz-e-Majlis Shura (Maulana Farooq Ahmad Kichloo) calls it baseless and seeks a public apology; Karra says she should resign if it proves false
The Army mistook the SPOs for militants as they returned from huntingTariq Hameed Karra, J&K Congress chiefA report from his district president, not verifiedR S Pathania (BJP): an unsubstantiated theory that casts aspersions on the forces
Police failed the men: unsafe route, weak arms, a shifted SOG camp, bodies in a dumperSunil Sharma and Shagun Parihar (BJP)Family visits; Sharma also alleges militants’ overground workers were hired as SPOsNo police reply reported
The killings undercut the claim of normalcy after Article 370Javed Rana, NC ministerPolitical argumentNone reported
A cowardly attack; operations under way to find the killers and the riflesLt Governor Manoj Sinha; officialsRifles missing from the sceneKarra disputes the militant framing

The security picture

Violence in Jammu and Kashmir is at its lowest in more than two decades, which is why two deaths in one district carry political weight.

SATP data via The Wire (2018–2025) and Indian Masterminds (2026 to 31 Oct). The 2025 total of 92 is as reported; its category figures sum to 91.

The decline is real, but analysts quoted by The Wire note that militancy has moved from the Valley into the Jammu region’s forests, where Kishtwar sits. May 2026 was the first month since 1990 with no terror-related death at all.

What two deaths weigh in 2026

The two SPOs are as many security personnel as had died in all of Jammu and Kashmir in the first ten months of the year.

SATP data via The Wire (2018–2025) and Indian Masterminds (2026 to 31 Oct); the two SPOs added from reports of 12 Nov.

That scale explains both sides of the argument. Javed Rana reads the killings as proof that normalcy claims are overstated; officials point to a toll that is a fraction of 2018’s. Neither reading tells us who fired in Dachhan.

Kishtwar’s pattern

Kishtwar has seen this before: men on duty taken in remote forest, rifles stolen, and the killings followed by sharp communal politics. Not every death of an SPO here has been militancy, though.

DateIncidentSource
Oct 2026SPO Bashir Ahmed found with his throat slit in Trigam forest; police arrested a father and son over a land dispute, not militancyIDRW/PTI
24 Jun 2026J&K Police book the commanding officer of 17 Rashtriya Rifles, a Major and 30–40 soldiers over an alleged assault on police at Atholi station; the Army promised to cooperateThePrint
22 Feb 2026Jaish commander Saifullah and two associates killed in the Chatroo forestsETV Bharat
18 Jan 2026A Special Forces havildar killed and eight soldiers hurt in Operation Trashi-I, ChatrooFree Press Journal
22 May 2025Soldier killed in a Chatroo gunfightDeccan Herald
7 Nov 2024Village Defence Guards Nazir Ahmad and Kuldeep Kumar abducted and shot in Kuntwara forest; Kashmir Tigers, a Jaish offshoot, claimed itGreater Kashmir
13 Apr 2020SPO Khursheed Iqbal hacked to death in Tandar, Dachhan; attackers took both SPOs’ riflesTribune
1 Nov 2018BJP state secretary Anil Parihar, Shagun Parihar’s father, and his brother Ajeet shot dead in Kishtwar townScroll

The base the two SPOs were heading to belonged to 17 Rashtriya Rifles, the unit at the centre of the June police–Army clash. That history is one reason any mistaken-identity question needs an answer from an inquiry, not from either party.

Share post:

spot_imgspot_img

Popular

More like this
Related

AISA Plans to Meet Minister Over Delhi Pollution as Neha Bora Rejects Centre’s Assurance

Late on Sunday, 15 November, the Union Environment Ministry...

Ghaziabad PMLA Court Sends Azam Khan to 10-Day Judicial Custody, He Will Be Lodged in Dasna Jail

Samajwadi Party leader and former Uttar Pradesh minister Mohammad...

Bilkis Bano Case: Supreme Court Bails Two Convicts After 17 Years

The Supreme Court has suspended the life sentences of...

“He was forced to drink acid”: 23-Year-Old Rehan Dies After Alleged Police Brutality

A 23-year-old Muslim man died in Faridabad jail on...